More Nagging About Seeking Truth
I mentioned a book a week or so ago, The Beginning of Infinity.
So far, it’s talking about seeking truth (explanations) versus seeking authority and certainty. On page 29 it says,
Old ways of thought, which did not seek good explanations, permitted no process such as science for correcting errors and misconceptions. Improvements happened so rarely that most people never experienced one.
Old ways of thought were unquestioned traditions.
It makes me wonder, as curious as I can be, do I actually have some areas I am unwilling to consider, to seek explanations?
Do I have assumptions about people, ideas, politics, even my feelings, that somewhere deep down I have no intention of exploring?
Are there some things I’d rather be wrong about than know the truth?
If you are like me, you see people fooling themselves all the time. But do you know when you’re doing it?
Certain persons, by swerving from these, have wandered away into vain discussion, desiring to be teachers of the law, without understanding either what they are saying or the things about which they make confident assertions. (1 Tim 1:6-7 ESV).
But wait, what were these “certain teachers” swerving from?
The aim of our charge is love that issues from a pure heart and a good conscience and a sincere faith. (1 Tim 1:5)
A pure heart, a good conscience, and a sincere faith. This makes sense. A pure heart cannot “make confident assertions” about something it doesn’t truly understand. Neither can “a good conscience” or “a sincere faith.”
Sincere Faith
Faith implies not having total objective certainty of knowledge. To pretend would leave you without “a good conscience.”
Thus, “an impure heart” shuts down honest truth seeking when it serves itself to believe a lie and then confidently assert it, either to itself or others.
There’s nothing wrong with having faith. I have loads of it. It’s just no good to confuse faith with sight.
It’s right and scary to be open to being wrong. That is, it is pure hearted to admit when faith is faith and certainty is certainty.
We should want to know what is true, versus what we need to be true. The author’s point in the above book as that true progress in the world started when thinkers in the Enlightenment were willing to seek explanations that he calls “a good explanation — hard to vary — it is not yours to modify…It is the ability of some of them to solve problems beyond those they were created to solve.”
His example of this was the “axis-tilt theory” for why seasons of earth change throughout the year. It’s the kind of knowledge that can be applied to any planet in the universe with pretty good certainty.
An example of a bad theory, according to the author, would be an earlier Greek version of why the seasons changed:
Long ago, Hades, god of the underworld, kidnapped and raped Persephone, goddess of spring. Then Persephone's mother, Demeter, goddess of the earth and agriculture, negotiated a contract for her daughter's release, which specified that Persephone would marry Hades and eat a magic seed that would compel her to visit him once a year thereafter. Whenever Persephone was away fulfilling this obligation, Demeter became sad and would command the world to become cold and bleak so that nothing could grow. P.19
It’s an explanation, but we know it’s a bad one, because we could not apply it to every planet. The Greeks created a “truth” that couldn’t be verifiably true or universally applied.
So I ask again, in what areas might I be fooling myself. Do I love the truth as much as I always say I do?
I will re-assert one of my more core values here: The outcome of the truth is the right outcome.
God, help us want to see and give us courage to accept what’s true.
So far, it’s talking about seeking truth (explanations) versus seeking authority and certainty. On page 29 it says,
Old ways of thought, which did not seek good explanations, permitted no process such as science for correcting errors and misconceptions. Improvements happened so rarely that most people never experienced one.
Old ways of thought were unquestioned traditions.
It makes me wonder, as curious as I can be, do I actually have some areas I am unwilling to consider, to seek explanations?
Do I have assumptions about people, ideas, politics, even my feelings, that somewhere deep down I have no intention of exploring?
Are there some things I’d rather be wrong about than know the truth?
If you are like me, you see people fooling themselves all the time. But do you know when you’re doing it?
Certain persons, by swerving from these, have wandered away into vain discussion, desiring to be teachers of the law, without understanding either what they are saying or the things about which they make confident assertions. (1 Tim 1:6-7 ESV).
But wait, what were these “certain teachers” swerving from?
The aim of our charge is love that issues from a pure heart and a good conscience and a sincere faith. (1 Tim 1:5)
A pure heart, a good conscience, and a sincere faith. This makes sense. A pure heart cannot “make confident assertions” about something it doesn’t truly understand. Neither can “a good conscience” or “a sincere faith.”
Sincere Faith
Faith implies not having total objective certainty of knowledge. To pretend would leave you without “a good conscience.”
Thus, “an impure heart” shuts down honest truth seeking when it serves itself to believe a lie and then confidently assert it, either to itself or others.
There’s nothing wrong with having faith. I have loads of it. It’s just no good to confuse faith with sight.
It’s right and scary to be open to being wrong. That is, it is pure hearted to admit when faith is faith and certainty is certainty.
We should want to know what is true, versus what we need to be true. The author’s point in the above book as that true progress in the world started when thinkers in the Enlightenment were willing to seek explanations that he calls “a good explanation — hard to vary — it is not yours to modify…It is the ability of some of them to solve problems beyond those they were created to solve.”
His example of this was the “axis-tilt theory” for why seasons of earth change throughout the year. It’s the kind of knowledge that can be applied to any planet in the universe with pretty good certainty.
An example of a bad theory, according to the author, would be an earlier Greek version of why the seasons changed:
Long ago, Hades, god of the underworld, kidnapped and raped Persephone, goddess of spring. Then Persephone's mother, Demeter, goddess of the earth and agriculture, negotiated a contract for her daughter's release, which specified that Persephone would marry Hades and eat a magic seed that would compel her to visit him once a year thereafter. Whenever Persephone was away fulfilling this obligation, Demeter became sad and would command the world to become cold and bleak so that nothing could grow. P.19
It’s an explanation, but we know it’s a bad one, because we could not apply it to every planet. The Greeks created a “truth” that couldn’t be verifiably true or universally applied.
So I ask again, in what areas might I be fooling myself. Do I love the truth as much as I always say I do?
I will re-assert one of my more core values here: The outcome of the truth is the right outcome.
God, help us want to see and give us courage to accept what’s true.
Posted in Nov 2024
Recent
Being A Biblical Human
September 7th, 2025
Unpause. Why I Just Couldn't Stay Away
September 7th, 2025
Anger In The Psalms. Am I Supposed To Get Angry?
September 7th, 2025
The Long Term Versus The Present
September 7th, 2025
What if Your Story Isn't Just Yours? 3 Signs Your Story Is Meant to Be Shared
September 7th, 2025
Archive
2025
September
Love for the Whole Body of Christ in BloNoThe Church that Equips for LifeJourney Church Bloomington NormalA Unique Perspective on "Sheep Stealing"Do Your Friends Make Your Life Better, Or Worse.Failing To Live Up To Your Standard?Wanting A King, A Dictator, Or An Authoritarian PastorSunday Thoughts About PrayerPick Yourself And Be Like Your CreatorBe Perfect. How You Can And What Happens When You Think You Can’t.Praying Enough? Here’s How To KnowI See The Appeal of Living a Life of Quiet Desperation Or…One Drawback to Being FocusedAbide, Dude. Just How Exactly Does One Abide In Christ?You Don’t Have To Be AloneIs The Hierarchy Of Needs Biblical?The Secret To Self Worth Is . . .You Know Your Values, Now What?To Be a World Champion Tennis Player, Let Your Poopy Earbud GoFocus On ValuesI Know the Source of All Your TroublesUnderstanding OurselvesJesus Had To Grow, Why Wouldn’t We?Marriage Sermon-Genesis 2:18-24How To Get God To Speak To YouWhat Then Does It Mean To Consider Others Better Than Ourselves?Discipleship Is Simple, But Not That SimpleSlow It Down, Wonderful Things Take TimeThe Body Against The Body-When Sin In The Church Needs To Be Brought To The LightFreedom Is Less Not MoreFour Steps To Do Anything-Getting UnstuckSunday BlessingsWe Can’t Do Anything Without ThisHow To Understand Other People, Even When You Don’t Want Them To Be RightShould There Be One Church?Giving Out Love Like Biscuits At BreakfastWhat A Kind Father With His RulesConquer Nature Not Men-Why I Don’t Like Socialism Or Christian NationalismA Meditation On Idolatry, Greatness, And Caring A LotHappening To You, Or For You?The Bible Says Transform By The Renewing Of The Mind, But How?Let’s Understand LeadershipWith Great Responsibility Comes Great Power Part 2Power, What Is It For?Leadership Is PowerHow We Compel People To Do StuffThe Character And Nature Of The LeaderThe Character And Nature Of The LeaderHow To Guarantee We Will Hurt Those We Lead: Don’t Respect ThemLeaders Who Love The Truth Trust God For The OutcomeYour Leader Passes Gas, And It SmellsConfident, But Not Arrogant, In ChristTruly Confident Leader, Part 2Leading? Be Very, Very Afraid. Especially If You Are A Good CommunicatorHow To Take Over The World, And Why You Shouldn’tBe Strong And Very Courageous, Leading Invites SabotageMaking The Most Of ItToss Your Old Identity Off The CliffThe Best Bible Verse For Anxiety-When Anxiety Keeps You From ChangingHow To Love Almost Any Life You Have Been GivenLoving Life While Hating ItWhy Did You Cry At That Sporting EventIs There Anything Sadder Than A Foolish Old PersonWhen One Part Of The Body SuffersJesus Is A PersonToday Is EternalMore Nagging About Seeking TruthThe Underestimated Power of the Public Reading of ScriptureShould Christians Read Secular Books?Thankfulness: A Spiritual, Emotional Necessity Part 2Thankfulness: A Spiritual, Emotional Necessity Part 1One More Thought About Secular BooksDiets And DiscipleshipMerry Day After ChristmasMerry ChristmasSurrender To God Is The Only Way To Go: 3 Reasons You May Not HaveMeeknessIf You Can Find Your CallingCharles Manson, Jim Jones, And MeWhat’s Always Missing From Pleas To GiveSubduing The Earth-Let’s Get It DoneWhat Story Are You Living In?What The Heck Is Wrong With You?What Happens When We Fool OurselvesConsume To Produce# 1 Quality Of A Great Leader-Non-AnxiousnessThe Myth Of The “Common:” Why Everything Belongs To GodThe Spiritual Discipline Of WritingAbundant Life Or ComfortEven Though You Feel Powerless, You Aren’tGodspeed Church NewsletterIf You’re Looking For A Healthy ChurchBiblical Humans On EasterThe Very Practical Resurrection LifeThe Power Of A Resurrected But Hidden LifeOpportunity Cost Or: The Secret To LifeSlow And Surrendered: The Biblical Wisdom Of A Non- ChristianShould A Christian Ever Say Anything Bad About A ChurchHow To Be Who You Really Are In ChristWhat if Your Story Isn't Just Yours? 3 Signs Your Story Is Meant to Be SharedThe Long Term Versus The Present
Categories
no categories

No Comments